Celtic Rumours Member Posts

 

ypf's Profile

Current Avatar:
ypf's Avatar
Correct Score Competition:

Not entered
Correct Score Competition
Flat Out Racing:

Not played Flat Out Racing


No Profile Picture uploaded

Team: Celtic


Where from:


Favourite player:


Best team moment:


Interests:


Timezone:




ypf's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To ypf's Posts

 

 

To ypf's last 5 rumours posts

 

To ypf's last 5 banter posts

 

To ypf's last 5 rumour replies

 

To ypf's last 5 banter replies

 

ypf's rumours posts with other poster's replies to ypf's rumours posts

 

23 Feb 2018 13:58:01
Play the strongest Celtic team for the rest of the season, no pissing about with BR changes, invest in the Summer and buy our own players. i reckon the loan players have an agreement where they have to play X amount of games in the SPL and EL, otherwise there is a penalty clause. With this in mind, Celtic players playing great probably get dropped for loan players playing poor to accommodate the loan agreement. Sometimes i despair the way the team play, but this is on the instruction of the manager and his game plan.

We need consistency in the team, (injuries permitting) let's get away from excuses like tired, travelled too far, the ball moved in the air, keeper cannot adjust. There is SPL football and EL football you can't get them mixed up. we lost 3 goals in the EL, if we scored them we would be heroes, that's the nature of the beast. Right, chins up, flags waving, let's get this league done pronto. hail hail.

ypf

 

 

23 Feb 2018 11:26:41
Not a good display last night, it was the same players/ team as last week, we don't seem to be savvy playing away from home in EL, again it was down to formation, tactics, fight and passion, once we learn not to concede or even get a draw away, we are good enough to beat the majority teams in EL at home, not impressed with Zenith team home or away.

BR's football philosophy and the realty is totally different, i know he's a fan wants to win, been a good run in EL and we need to spend some money and buy our own players, build a solid team, this team is constantly changing with injuries and loans, hopefully get the treble this season, but i can see a lot of changes coming for next season. keep the faith, its only football. hail hail.

ypf

 

 

21 Feb 2018 13:21:18
Alrighty, what's the postees thinking about the spl split, good idea bad idea, like it, hate it, scrap it, keep it?

ypf

1.) 21 Feb 2018 15:49:04
Never liked it
Get rid.


2.) 21 Feb 2018 16:13:16
The alternatives are a larger league, which I'm against; or playing each team four times, which I'm also against. It's a bit daft that a team can finish on more points than another, but still be below them. However, sometimes the devil you know and all that and I suppose it's different, and adds a bit of an edge.


3.) 21 Feb 2018 19:32:44
I'd like to see more teams in the league rather than keep the split. playing teams 4 times a season gets tedious to be honest.


4.) 21 Feb 2018 21:45:08
Larger league for me, share the wealth and bigger gates with more teams.


5.) 22 Feb 2018 05:23:46
I would like to see a league of 14.

Play other other home/ away = 26 games

Top 7/ Bottom 7 and play each other home/ away = 12 games.

Gives you 38 games.

That would be to simple for the SPFL though.


6.) 22 Feb 2018 17:34:02
Two top league of 18 with regional leagues below the rest.

More competition. Unlikely though as greedy wee teams like killie, Hamilton, Ross County, etc. Wouldn't want to give up their extra game (s) against us and sevco.


7.) 22 Feb 2018 17:40:47
Although I like the idea of a bigger league, the problem with your suggestion KH is that one team would be left not playing on the last day in both the bottom and top sections as there is an odd number in each section of the league. To ensure fairness there is no way one team would be allowed to finish their campaign before others.


 

 

10 Feb 2018 15:24:15
Celtic v Partick: It was a win, but not impressed, Celtic won so many games against poor league teams and the treble came along with that, although the treble team and players were more up for it and showed hunger and passion. Most are still there.?

Messing about with loans is my bug bearer, i want to buy players who are our players and play for the wages we pay them and for the shirt/ fans, to be part of the Celtic family. not someone who thinks i am only here for x amount of time then am back to my own team mentality player. We need to BUY. Don't mind young Scottish talent at least they have played this league.

Young loan players: Some are just too young for our game, these £15 - £20 million players can't get a game for their own team why should we play them in our team, I would not buy any of them, even Roberts has had his day at Celtic not worth the 15 million.
Sad to say we will probably never see a big money buy in the Scotland leagues.

BR: has he been sussed out by other teams, has he seen the light in the mickey mouse league with no money to buy?

Kennedy: should have never got a job as a coach at Celtic: need a more experience coach. don't know who though.

Celtic v Zenith: I am hoping its going to be one of those glory nights in Europe at paradise and our best team turns up.

Dembele: 30 Million, Someone is definitely having a laugh. let's hope he hits the net with Zenith, might change my mind.

Hail Hail.

ypf

1.) 10 Feb 2018 16:25:33
Worst post I’ve read in a long time wtf are you on.
Loan players right here we go do we choose players we can afford and hope to fk that they make the grade cos if they do they move on after 2 yrs profit in bank but if they don’t we’re done yet loan players allow us to afford better than what we can afford yet no risk. I support the Celtic football club not the Celtic plc so to me it’s what happens on the pitch that counts.
You’ve slated Roberts have u actually watches that Bhoy play at full fitness streaks ahead of anyone we’ve signed in that position in years and I for one love seeing him pull on the hoops.
Musonda 2 games in give him a chance this Bhoy will rip this league apart.
Dembele oh he’s shite 🙈
I tell u I love this site ed but some of the shite spouted by people on here is unreal either old fans living in the Stein era or new ones expecting the world drives me up the wall at times.


2.) 10 Feb 2018 17:18:28
Zactly welshboy, either a Hun in disguise or the guy is tripping bawlz.


3.) 10 Feb 2018 17:26:00
Agreed welsbhoy. The negative bulls**t coming from some posters is ridiculous. They talk about loans this loans that. Welcome to the new world of football we're Celtic FC we no longer can afford to break the bank on exceptionally talented footballers. Anything from the youth team is great and any players half decent we can tie down for 18-30months on loan is a bargain. If any fans like me want to see Celtic FC be a house hold name in Europe (at least participating in the comp ) then we need to accept that this is the way forward.

As for mousonda got a wee bit of learning to do but by far one of the most technically gifted players in our team and can offer that edge against European opposition.

I for one have complete faith in Brendan with only a handful of defeats. We still appear to be in a better position than last season with European football and a treble still available. Our squad is stronger when all players fit, I just hope we show up and play to our best of ability and take a result over to Russia.
Hail hail.


4.) 11 Feb 2018 00:59:28
Welshbhoy: good comments, I too support the team on the park and happy to be were we are at and what we have acheived.
my love for the team will never die.

Loan players: how many we bought and made a profit on so far? i don't know this answer. my own take is rather buys players develop then profit. ( personal opinion )
.
Roberts: Never slated him as a player said he's had his day ( 2 Loans for him ) . I watched him at city and celtic, What am saying is he's not worth the money quoted and if cheaper i would take him. when forest turns up roberts would'nt get in and visa versa.

Musonda: like many on here am saying needs to bulk up, hopefully that will come, but has the skill to do a job for us, but we will never own him, ( wish we couyld ) and not up to speed for the physical side of our league. (only a boy in a man's game. just now )

Dembele: I only stated not worth 30 million ( never mention sh1t) , we know he has the skill to put the baw in the net and cause havoc with all the spl teams and european teams.

HH.


5.) 11 Feb 2018 19:16:29
Your comments which you are entitled to are poor in my opinion. Or wishful thinking of another nature. Your team if they are have won the treble, are sitting top of the league, won league cup, in quarter final of Scottish cup at home. . In Europe after Xmas. All whilst not hitting top form. God help teams when they do. Your criticism is panty wetter way way over the top and unwarranted again in my view. I bet you could turn a lottery win into bad news.


6.) 11 Feb 2018 19:29:01
We've no been great this season but last season was always going to be hard to copy performance wise but we're still on for the double treble which would be awesome, I think in Europe we've been just as bad as last season but we've had 2 hard groups to be fair and to many players have been off form this season but I think we're all guilty of maybe taking winning and maybe being a little too hard on players.


7.) 11 Feb 2018 22:56:12
Kwaj, maybe i am missing something here but on my post i have not criticised the team in any, i am one mighty happy Celtic fan at what the team has achieved and were we are now. no worries there, i would take a crappy win any day. it was my personal opinion on Loan players.


8.) 13 Feb 2018 23:29:07
YPF
There is definitely a whiff of negativity in your post .
Taking in loan players is a legitimate tactic by all clubs both big and small . I can't understand your problem with Celtic taking on loan players, even PSG have a loan player and I don't think their fans criticise them . Manchester United have had loan players in recent yrs and didn't Chelsea try to sign Andy Carroll and big Peter C but couldn't because both players were injured.


9.) 14 Feb 2018 10:55:24
cheers chris, not against them, my feelings are that we should spend and buy players and build a team a ( money permitting ) and use the development team and then loans. Negativity:let him who is without sin cast the first stone.


10.) 14 Feb 2018 22:05:27
Ypf. You won't have to seek out a stone for a very long time, as you would be at the end of the line by your amount of negativity.


 

 

29 Jan 2018 23:54:40
Whats happening with all these loans clubs are pulling in and moving out, is this a sign of the times, or they don't want to buy players (no Money)

I am not a great fan of loans but understand the need for them, but the teams that can afford it should be buying the players so the team can develop a player for long term or to sell on. It's like pay as u play players now.

If Br fails in the 10 in row, he will leave, if he make it to 10 he will leave just after.

All comments welcome, H. H. the celts are here.

ypf

1.) 30 Jan 2018 12:06:37
I don't think the loans we are getting are a problem as they are for players out with our budget. 18 months we are guaranteed even if you buy a player doesn't mean they will stay that long. If we were loaning the likes of Murphy or Sean Goss then I would be concerned. We have Patrick Roberts and Charly Musonda. Real quality. These guys improve our team and with Sinclair Dembele Forrest Rogic and Ntcham coming onto a game no team will enjoy playing against. Hopefully beginning with Hearts tonight.


 

 

 

ypf's banter posts with other poster's replies to ypf's banter posts

 

05 May 2018 19:02:26
St Johnstone put 5 past Muderwell, at their gaff, if we don't hammer them in cup, there is no excuse and no hiding place, it would be an embarrassment. The cup is a given.

4 games to go i am looking for a goal feast, and one of our strikers to steal top spot. 5 fudds ahead of us, lafferty . we owe the tarts a gubbing tomorrow. hail hail.

ypf

1.) 05 May 2018 20:38:51
They were saving themselves for the cup, it will be a different team attitude and commitment wise for the final, it would be foolish to think it will be a walk over., although it might well be.


2.) 05 May 2018 22:32:27
They only have cup to play for and have downed tools to save themselves for it.
All it takes is a couple a dodgy decisions or a bit of bad luck.
Nothing is a given. We should know better than that.
We are entitled to nothing.
One more that them will do me fine.


3.) 05 May 2018 23:22:37
A given? Nothing is a given and to say so lowers us to the Sevco mentality of self importance. Was the Kilmarnock defeat a given? Or the home draw against Dundee? We should win the treble but it's not a given and if Murderwell turn up they are capable of a result if we are off the boil on the day. Wasn't that long ago Ross County put us out in a Hampden semi. Every team deserves respect.

{Ed007's Note - Spot on for me, Rab. The same Motherwell we've drew twice with this season.}


4.) 06 May 2018 09:56:43
Dont read too much into Motherwell result yesterday. All they have to play for is cup final. However they have Partick and Hamilton in their last 2 games who are fighting for their lives do maybe expect Motherwell to lose or draw next 2 but they will be in our faces on the day don't doubt that. No pushover this one.


5.) 06 May 2018 11:01:20
who do you think will win Celtic v Motherwell in the cup final.

Should i be worried that the crappy motherwell are going to turn us over and deny us the opportunity for a double treble. That they are saving themselves to play against 30 million pound striker and and 20 million pound defender and the player of the year. They can save a much as they want. their savings amount to hee haw.
I understand i used the word a given and you all say there is not such thing as a given. We know the underdog and has a chance.
It's going to take a good shot with that sling to slay goliath.


 

 

01 May 2018 07:35:18
Happy Month of May, you bunch of Championees. Hail. Hail.

ypf

 

 

27 Apr 2018 18:54:01
wee shout out for the jags on saturday, mon the theestle. good to keep the glesga team in the league, short trip for the selik. Hail Hal, soon be Sunday.

ypf

1.) 27 Apr 2018 19:11:50
Always had a soft spot for the Jags, be great if they stay up.


 

 

27 Apr 2018 11:44:54
Looks like Celtic need to play 8 games to get to the CL draw, anyone confirm that, if so, that's crazy for a team that won their domestic league.

ypf

{Ed007's Note - We've known for quite a while that we'd need to play 4 qualifying rounds from next season.}


1.) 27 Apr 2018 11:56:44
Yeh that’s been happening for a while now! Because the top 4 or 5 countries get an automatic 4 teams straight into it from next season! It’s an absolute farce and the name of the competition should be ‘let’s make as much money for the bigger countries league’ could go on all day about what a joke football has turned into, but what’s the point! Give it time and countries like ours won’t be involved at all in things like this! Apart from watching us play I’ve found myself going right off watchn any other football, and especially the ‘champions league’ just absolutely scunnered with it to be honest! And I never thought I’d hear myself say that.

{Ed007's Note - The quicker they bugger off to form their Super League the better imo.}


2.) 27 Apr 2018 12:13:40
Couldn't agree more boys, if Liverpool win it this year it makes it even bigger a farce. How a team that haven't won their own league since 1990 can be champs of Europe is beyond a joke.

{Ed007's Note - I wouldn't worry about Liverpool winning the CL. Since Barca went out every other team's just playing to see who Real Madrid beat in the final.}


3.) 27 Apr 2018 12:21:52
I can only watch Celtic and up til recently Scotland the rest means nothing to me used to be able to watch any game at any time and get into it.


4.) 27 Apr 2018 12:54:25
It will be 8 games if we have four rounds.

{Ed007's Note - Did you work that out all by yourself?}


5.) 27 Apr 2018 13:02:42
Scotland. just read they are charging £88, yea 88 quid a ticket to watch Peru. it's enough to make an injun strike his chief.

{Ed007's Note - That's scandalous!}


6.) 27 Apr 2018 13:03:49
Think there was a clue in my post.


7.) 27 Apr 2018 14:35:48
Ed I think Liverpool will beat Roma next week so at least we go into the CL qualifiers as a seeded team. Not much consolation but better than nothing.

{Ed007's Note - I don't know, Johnny, Roma haven't conceded at home in the CL this year and if they can get an early goal hopefully the Scouser's ar$e collapses.}


8.) 27 Apr 2018 15:51:46
I’ve seen people saying it will be more difficult to qualify which tbh isn’t really the case. The level of opposition will be lower than our usual first qualifier. It might actually work out well as it should be like playing 2 friendliest but with a competitive edge.

{Ed007's Note - That's the way I see it too, Kev. }


9.) 27 Apr 2018 17:14:08
I have wondered in the past few years why the name Champions league has never been challenged in court by some of the more outlandish team owners who get screwed over similar to our situation.


10.) 27 Apr 2018 17:31:12
The so called Champions League is a total joke.


11.) 27 Apr 2018 17:34:33
Roma good team at home and not concede, Liverpool defence query, if Roma can put 3 passed Barcelona then they can do it with Liverpool, but i think Liverpool will be the first team to score against them in Cl, cannot write off their attackers.

{Ed007's Note - And who would have wrote off Barca's? I do think they'll score but it will be interesting if they concede first I reckon.}


12.) 27 Apr 2018 17:43:22
Ed you need to work on your sarcasm having just read your response to Magicpole and spilt my Guinness doon my new t-shirt. The wife will go nuts! 😂👍☘️.

{Ed007's Note - :-D


13.) 27 Apr 2018 18:02:53
I know, 2 of them, i think they are called messi and suarez,


14.) 28 Apr 2018 11:30:56
I don’t have a problem with having the qualifiers if we are equipped to win them. Which we should be. They are competitive games, get us focused and they will add at least another £6m into the coffers with the gates and TV money. That’s treble what Sevco will earn the whole season.

Get the players we know we need and it’s a win win. Ready for the league and poakits bulging with cash. Bring it on.


15.) 28 Apr 2018 11:35:43
My answer about the number of games was one of how many games do you think four rounds is? Should have worded it better. :) don’t mind a bit of sarcasm, especially when you set yourself up for it.


 

 

08 Apr 2018 20:13:41
I am beginning to think BR will be away soon, this season or next, reason being he is now discovering not only what this league is all about.

Big money signing's he will never make. (maybe one) , working with loan players.

Teams not turning up to play football

SFA corruption / biased, religious bigotry which he believed he was getting away from.

There is only so much you can do for the love of a team, then you need to wake up and smell the coffee.

When the PL comes calling he would make 10mill per year and spend 40-80 mill on players to build a team.

Enjoy it while we have it. Hail Hail.

ypf

1.) 08 Apr 2018 20:35:51
He may leave, be may not. One thing you said is incorrect tho. He didn't think he was getting away from religious bigotry. Not coming to Celtic. He would have been fully aware what he was coming to.


2.) 08 Apr 2018 20:43:54
ypf: just how much have you had to drink mate, obv too much.
BR is worth circa £16m. He is not only our manager, he is also a fan and for him making HIS mark at Celtic ( legacy) is everything.


3.) 08 Apr 2018 20:59:19
I can’t see him leaving, but I certainly see the reasoning why he should.
We’re fortunate to have a fan as the manager and I can’t see him leave before ten in a row ✊🍀🇮🇪.


4.) 08 Apr 2018 21:02:12
Well said Peterbhoy. Ypf he will like all managers leave but hopefully not this season or next. He knew exactly what he was coming to.


5.) 08 Apr 2018 22:06:36
Good comments, always good to hear your thoughts.

Peterboy: Agree he's worth more and will get more, i used a basic ball park figure, (p. s. am tee total these day's, maybe that's what's wrong. His legacy already confirmed,

Shugmckie: Different types of bigotry from accross the water and here. petty in Scotland and corrupt sfa and people playing at it.

Johhnymac: I hope he stays and takes us to the CL/ EL level.
hail hail I want the 10IAR just like my fellow Tic Fans.


6.) 08 Apr 2018 22:10:12
Being a self-confessed Celtic supporter, he is only too well aware of the obstacles, handicaps and hindrances of being our manager.
The fact that he has made history already and can do so again will be a good incentive for the time being. However EVERY manager has a shelf life and will leave for one reason or another.
The summer transfer window will be a good indication of the manager and the clubs ambition and objectives and hopefully it will also give the support optimism for more great things and success for Celtic.


7.) 08 Apr 2018 23:45:45
Ypf is that your dream list? Brendan to leave for the reasons stated . If you are right Brendan would only be confirming he was a very stupid man . He has often spoke about her he and his family and uncles were great Celtic supporters, surely he knew our problems before he joined.


8.) 09 Apr 2018 07:12:49
Sounds like someday read provan yesterday.


9.) 09 Apr 2018 09:30:43
@Old man Chris once again you either failed to read the post or you did read it, and thought is said something completely different

Think you missed my dream list at the end of my post.
I hope he stays and takes us to the CL/ EL higher level. I want the 10IAR just like my fellow Tic Fans.
Celtic should match a Pl offer in wages to keep him if it
happens.

Buzzing for Sunday and is only Monday. Hail Hail.


10.) 09 Apr 2018 10:39:47
It’s a matter of when, not if Rogers leaves. He says to the players, if you want a big move then you need to perform, not just in the SPFL, but in the CL.

That is the same deal for him. Nobody down south gives a rats arse about our league. The only way Rogers ensures he gets the right offers to suit his self worth is to make us a recognised CL team, as was his stated objective, echoed by Lawell.

We all know that hasn’t happened. If anything this year saw us lose 5 games, including three at home. Our defence isn’t good enough for here, never mind the CL. Not addressing that has been a major failure to accept the blatant reality that we don’t have good enough defenders.

It has to be fifth time lucky in the summer. Until Rogers takes us into a CL group and we aren’t routinely embarrassed he isn’t going to any big team.

This knowledge I hope will redouble his efforts to fix a defence that cannot keep weans oot a close and lift the whole team.

Another CL campaign, which isn’t guaranteed with four games now with the same rubbish defence, of getting 5 and 6 goals thumped in, won’t have clubs chasing him.

Conversely, if he dies sort out our Achilles heel and we out uo a show, then clubs say, he has done that with feck all money, what could he do with £100m to spend.

I can’t believe we are still in the position of having a crap defence after four windows. Rangers have a chance, solely because of this and no matter how much we love him, that’s not good management of the situation.

Sort the defence, put up a good show in Europe or it’s the Everton’s of this world he will be heading to.

He must know that. If he doesn’t that’s a worry.


11.) 09 Apr 2018 23:49:31
Ypf surely you started your post with complete negative nonsense . I am getting old and haven't got that much time left . I don't want tonspoil my sane years left reading a big lump of negativity .

Of course I am delighted now to know you don't believe your thoughts .
We both are looking foreward to Sunday.


 

 

 

ypf's rumour replies

 

Click To View This Thread

12 May 2018 12:08:09
If you have wee bit extra you can always afford a pudding.

To hell with the poverty give the cat the budgie.
Light up paradise and the fans will come.

ypf

 

 

Click To View This Thread

10 May 2018 18:37:32
if there is no cl/ el then they can rent it out as an events venue = revenue. There's always a bigger picture.

ypf

 

 

Click To View This Thread

14 Feb 2018 10:55:24
cheers chris, not against them, my feelings are that we should spend and buy players and build a team a ( money permitting ) and use the development team and then loans. Negativity:let him who is without sin cast the first stone.

ypf

 

 

Click To View This Thread

11 Feb 2018 22:56:12
Kwaj, maybe i am missing something here but on my post i have not criticised the team in any, i am one mighty happy Celtic fan at what the team has achieved and were we are now. no worries there, i would take a crappy win any day. it was my personal opinion on Loan players.

ypf

 

 

Click To View This Thread

11 Feb 2018 00:59:28
Welshbhoy: good comments, I too support the team on the park and happy to be were we are at and what we have acheived.
my love for the team will never die.

Loan players: how many we bought and made a profit on so far? i don't know this answer. my own take is rather buys players develop then profit. ( personal opinion )
.
Roberts: Never slated him as a player said he's had his day ( 2 Loans for him ) . I watched him at city and celtic, What am saying is he's not worth the money quoted and if cheaper i would take him. when forest turns up roberts would'nt get in and visa versa.

Musonda: like many on here am saying needs to bulk up, hopefully that will come, but has the skill to do a job for us, but we will never own him, ( wish we couyld ) and not up to speed for the physical side of our league. (only a boy in a man's game. just now )

Dembele: I only stated not worth 30 million ( never mention sh1t) , we know he has the skill to put the baw in the net and cause havoc with all the spl teams and european teams.

HH.

ypf

 

 

 

ypf's banter replies

 

Click To View This Thread

15 May 2018 11:34:00
not telling anyone how to act ed, suggested that there are other ways rather than football games.

ypf

{Ed001's Note - no, you told them that they should go and take up arms if they disagreed rather than waving a flag. That is telling someone how to act.}


 

 

Click To View This Thread

15 May 2018 11:38:07
@fgjmarktwo respect your comments, condescending, let me apologise on the way it came across. I feel that we should be steering away from politics in football.

ypf

 

 

Click To View This Thread

15 May 2018 11:19:58
The point Ed. I never disagreed with people's right to protest, i disagree with it being at at football game. I can't make it any clearer than that.

ypf

{Ed001's Note - and so do I, but that is the point, I just disagree not think I can come on and give it all the holier-than-thou crap and tell them they should do something else. Everyone has the right to choose. They choose to show their displeasure via a few flags, I really do not see why you think you have a right to tell them how to act.}


 

 

Click To View This Thread

15 May 2018 10:50:16
Ed my bottom line is do something about it at if you feel the need to do it. but not at a football stadium. simples.

ypf

{Ed001's Note - they are doing something....whether you disagree or not it is their right to protest.}


 

 

Click To View This Thread

15 May 2018 10:08:07
Ypf has seen witnessed at first hand people killing themselves over religion/ race/ land/ power/ greed.

I don't know how old you are fgimarktwo, but my post is we should be waving flags for the celtic football club and not for political reason. If you are young everything will become clear to you when the time is right.
The celtic banter page is a football page and chat for football
(why i joined) not political. although their is room for tangents
I suggested the person or persons who feel the need to save these people should join them in their struggle. If that takes a weapon or peace campaign so bit it their choice.

@Fgimarktwo sometimes we are too scared to look in the mirror to see who the killers are, or were, and who paid money to support their fight. There is no freedom with the hand of a gun only death and destruction and the people suffer.

Support your team enjoy yourselves and live life. Hail Hail.

ypf

{Ed001's Note - by your reckoning, no one should give money to charity unless they are prepared to run a marathon for the cause then? Everyone should surely do what they can, no matter how small it is, to help or the world will stay a mess if we all take your blasé attitude to it.}