30 Nov 2013 18:13:37
Hi Ed, had a discussion with my dad today, he was on about the holy goalies blunder last week, anyway basically we were divided on the best Celtic keeper since the 80's, for me it's the holy goalie himself, Big Pat second and FF third. Any chance of a pool {Ed007's Note - Sure mate, I'll give it a couple of hours incase anyone wants to nominate anyone else.}

1.) 30 Nov 2013
Charbonier was a crackin keeper lol just ended up a greedy d**k

GunnieBhoy

2.) 30 Nov 2013
I agree with your selections. But what about the 3 worst goalkeepers .I would go for 1. Ian Andrews 2.Carl Muggleton 3.Gordon Marshall.
67Coatbridge
.PS Well Done to The Wee Rovers {Ed007's Note - A cracking result for Albion today and I do enjoy seeing Motherwell getting beaten.}

3.) 30 Nov 2013
Charbonier? A assume we're talking celtic goalies. Sanchez Broto was the same good but greedy.
Can't disagree with op choices

4.) 30 Nov 2013
Anthony Warner must be up there?!

Bigbadjohn

5.) 30 Nov 2013
Douglas must have been the worst

6.) 30 Nov 2013
Gould by a mile for me as the worst

7.) 30 Nov 2013
He took a bit of stick but Hedman was a great keeper for me. If I remember right he had amazing clean sheet stats!

joeshmo1888 {Ed007's Note - In 3 seasons he played 37 matches with 23 clean sheets, a percentage of 62.16% (I'm checking GK's for the survey that's how I have that info at hand lol)

8.) 30 Nov 2013
No criticism of Big paddy B? I have always thought he was a very average keeper myself.In all the years I watched him I cannot recall him making an outstanding save!

9.) 30 Nov 2013
Packie was as big a bombscare as any keeper we've had re crosses and commanding his area but as good as any re shotstopping, similar to ff overall boruc was the best for me, I also thought broto loked promising but for the life of me can't remember what happened with him and why he didn't sign,,,, deep river bhoy

10.) 30 Nov 2013
Agree there re PB, he was like a vampire, couldn't handle thrm crosses at all

11.) 30 Nov 2013
Wow, thought u were a total Stato their Ed. God bless Google eh!
Agreed GJ.Big Packie was a legend as a Celt.but his actual keeping scared me at times. still love the big guy all the same.

joeshmo1888 {Ed007's Note - I'm not that bad.....yet. I do sometimes think I have a bit of a photographic memory at times. The stupid, even pointless stuff I know is unreal :) I do loads of reading about various subjects and enjoy watching quiz shows etc I'd love to have the guts to apply to go on one but that's never happening.}

12.) 30 Nov 2013
Think broto got greedy ended up back in spain

13.) 30 Nov 2013
Best for me was big Packy, with Andrews easily the worst.

14.) 01 Dec 2013
Ma mistake canny believe a wrote charbonier meant javier sanchez broto. Don't know how the f a got them mixed up

GunnieBhoy

{Ed007's Note - You'll need to work hard to make us forget this one GB. I spotted it right away but decided that I didn't even know who you could have meant so let it slide to find out.}

15.) 01 Dec 2013
Haha a know ed really don't know where a got charbonier from. Min a read the comments and seen it a burst out laughin with embarrassment. GunnieBhoy

16.) 01 Dec 2013
@2 worst keepers, Magnus headman has to be in there, I know he was good at Coventry but his Celtic spell was a disaster.

17.) 01 Dec 2013
Sort yourself out ed and get applying, you have a ready made support here. You only live once mucker, no regrets
HH joe

{Ed007's Note - Then you end up going on and freeze up, no way lol}

18.) 01 Dec 2013
The problem you have applying for a quiz show Ed is that they have to see your coupon first. which will scare them right off.none on the radio for you? Hee Hee.

joeshmo1888

{Ed007's Note - Cheers mate :)

19.) 01 Dec 2013
Radio 2 pop master. Get yerself on there ed great first cuppa at work listening to that for years. The newbs all listen to capital now and it kills my brain a little every time the same 7 songs loop all day.
ParadiseAndy.

{Ed007's Note - I listen to internet radio stations (usually geeky stuff like Alex Jones or Coast to Coast AM). Music died for me when Oasis broke up, so if it is music it is pre-Oasis split stuff, The Stone Roses etc a lot of 60's tunes, Pink Floyd, stuff like that, even old 'classic' rap gets the occasional airing.
Now we all know how our parents felt when we put Ebeneezer Goode on back in the 90's with the $hite that is called music today.
I have made a mistake, I do still enjoy some of Eminem's stuff but it's not as good as his early albums.
Programmes like X-Factor have destroyed modern music, and people are embarrassed about 80's music in general with all the New Romantic muck. Come the revolution, wait until people look back on this era and cringe!!}