16 Apr 2018 16:31:13
Right bhoys where do we all stand on Tommy Rogic? I was of the opinion that it would probably be best to look for at least somebody to challenge, and in time, replace him, given his fitness record. However since he's came back into the side, and done what he's done. I'm torn. Would it be foolish to give him a bumper deal? Or is it a no brainer given his talent. Can we afford the luxury of having a player who might miss half a season, but is one of the first names on the sheet when he's fit.

1.) 16 Apr 2018
16 Apr 2018 17:06:28
It's a no brainer me JT any big game player / big goalscorer stays IMO again if the boy was " problem free " he would easily command bigger wages than he does now elsewhere

I will say this for him every time he returns home he waxes lyrical about Celtic (Y)

2.) 16 Apr 2018
16 Apr 2018 17:09:01
4 year deal please.

3.) 16 Apr 2018
16 Apr 2018 18:12:47
I would love him to renew as he is an outstanding player. The only thing that he is missing is pace but I think his quickness of thought and close control compensate for that.

Let's hope we manage to tie him up on a new contract and we get at least another 2 seasons out of him.

4.) 16 Apr 2018
16 Apr 2018 18:56:10
It was evident when he was missing that we lacked his class and our play was very predictable. However, he has always had a stamina and fitness issue - so it's not a new dilemma.
I think - even if he does miss a number of games - it's a real bonus to have someone who can create goals/ chances out of nothing, especially during the run-in, when others are tiring/ jaded and he is like a new signing with big goals in big games every time.
Tam Must Stay.

5.) 16 Apr 2018
16 Apr 2018 20:57:18
JimTim: I asked a week or 2 ago, if you had the choice and could only pick 1 player. which one would you keep.

Rogic or Armstrong.

2 players of different qualities.

Who would you keep, as it looks like Armstrong will leave Keep Rogic.
Pick 1 = Armstrong.
Cpould we keep the 2 then yes please.

6.) 16 Apr 2018
16 Apr 2018 22:32:53
That's a tough one Peter. If I could only pick one it would probably be Armstrong. Slightly different players as you say though. I think the replies here have made up my mind. Feck it, sign Rogic up. When he is fit he's a joy to watch and it costs serious money to get a player of his quality right now. As for Armstrong, I'm expecting to move on. The manner of his last extension suggests he sees the time as being soon.

7.) 18 Apr 2018
18 Apr 2018 22:00:40
My opinion of Tom Rogic is the same this week as last week and other weeks .
At times on Sunday Rogic was excellent but at other times he let the game run past him . Most of us that like Rogic would love more Rogic.