26 Nov 2017 17:32:10
Disappointed with Sinclair at the penalty. He's not the first nor the last to do that but hate to see it. Feel we would have won without the pen. Surely now James Forrest has put to bed the does he doesn't he debate? . The bhoy was outstanding ☘ oh and get the bhoy Moult in this January. reminds me of big bad John.

1.) 26 Nov 2017
26 Nov 2017 17:41:55
I posted my disgust on fb . Poor ref decision . Went down too easy . Ref was equalling the bad challenge on dembelle. Still shocking . Never a penalty nor a red card.

2.) 26 Nov 2017
26 Nov 2017 18:13:23
Hope Sinclair is man enough to feel a bit of guilt about it. Boy should have walked earlier but still. Some may say is a part of the game to do what Scoťt did but even if it is, it’s a lazy part of the game which lacks honesty.

3.) 26 Nov 2017
26 Nov 2017 18:16:34
Thomson should never get another final. pish poor referee.

4.) 26 Nov 2017
26 Nov 2017 18:21:05
Was never a pen, if a decision like that today went against us we'd all be raging. Personally i don't see it as cheating by Sinclair, i see it as poor refereeing from Thompson. He has to be stronger in that situation. There was minimal contact on Sinclair but no where near enough to merit a penalty never mind a red card. Very very poor decision by Thompson yet again.

5.) 26 Nov 2017
26 Nov 2017 18:22:06
I hate that sort of thing in football we would have won without that IMO It was a dive.

6.) 26 Nov 2017
26 Nov 2017 18:33:52
I totally disagree, Sinclair certainly isn’t a cheat as you both state, he was taken down deliberately by his left shoulder.
Definitely not a sending off though but he should have been sent off with that ridiculous chanange on Dembele. Well done Celtic, well deserved winners in any ways, the best team won. 👏🍀🇮🇪.

{Ed007's Note - After the game I seen it from an angle behind the goal and you can see where Kipre pulled on Sinclairs left arm/shoulder, in slow motion it looks soft but when you think that Sinclair is running full pelt it wouldn't take much to knock him off his feet. The red card decision was a strange one.}

7.) 26 Nov 2017
26 Nov 2017 18:55:23
The centre half should’ve been off after about 10mins for foul on Dembele, McHugh should’ve been off, Sinclair should’ve been booked for diving, ref was pretty poor. I thought overall we done enough to win, it’s another trophy and the double treble will prob rest on winning the Scottish Cup, but I agree, think we need couple new players that will improve team again👍.

8.) 26 Nov 2017
26 Nov 2017 19:04:11
It doesn't befit a Celtic player and although we could argue all day about decisions going for and against us over the years, Thomson compounded a poor display with a shocker that only he can explain and the best team won.

9.) 26 Nov 2017
26 Nov 2017 19:47:07
😂😂 what chance have refs got. Slaughtered for every decision that goes against us and slaughtered for a decision that goes our way. What a world we live in.

10.) 26 Nov 2017
26 Nov 2017 19:53:56
what a lot of crap , fair play its a contact sport no arguments there, but the boy lifted his hands to impede sinclair no matter how soft you all think it was , it was a foul and outside the box noone wouldve even blinked an eye its only because the boy got a red card ( which was totally wrong by the ref ) that everyones going on about it, sinclair never cheated end off the day we won the cup.

11.) 26 Nov 2017
26 Nov 2017 20:15:32
Oh well 😂.

12.) 26 Nov 2017
26 Nov 2017 20:28:06
It was a penalty but ref got it wrong by giving a red card because it is only a yellow if you award the penalty.

13.) 26 Nov 2017
26 Nov 2017 22:14:06
Enjoyed the difference in replies to my post bhoys that's what these sites are about. Another trophy in the bag lads God bless . Hail Hail ☘.

14.) 27 Nov 2017
27 Nov 2017 09:18:48
Like Sinclair said after the game, he felt a contact so he went down, but that's all wrong, you shouldn't go down just because you feel a contact, you shouldn't go down at all, you should get put down, or get impeded, so you can't do what you want, before the ref gives a penalty, every thing else is just plain diving, was listening to talksport last night, they were discussing the very thing, don't know who was talking, some ex professional, but think he was saying yeah it was better to go down and get the penalty rather than carry on and have a chance of scoring, that kind of thinking needs to be taken out of football.

15.) 27 Nov 2017
27 Nov 2017 09:22:45
The speed Sinclair was running at I thought it was a stone Waller. Now I'm home and seen it there is minimal contact but I will take it all day long! Many a times theses type of descions have been against us but $hit happens.

16.) 27 Nov 2017
27 Nov 2017 09:23:50
It maybe wasn't a penalty, but who cares, we won a cup, why the big debate about Sinclair diving and not the shocking challenge that player put into dembele.
Let’s stop all this holier than now crap, and accept it’s a part of the game nowadays.

17.) 27 Nov 2017
27 Nov 2017 22:35:36
I couldn't see what exactly happened whilst match was going on as I was down in the corner that Celtic were defending . Based on what I saw in clips after the game there was decent contract and as the MSSM tell us freguently when the pboot is on the other foot and A pen is awarded against Celtic, the Well defender give the ref reason to award pen .
The new rules indicate that ref having given penalty was correct to give red card .
Football is a game of opinions and everyone is entitled to their opinion .
What is questionable on a Celtic forum is to quote from Talk Sport . Talk Sport is as bias as Radio Clyde with big D Johnstone spouting his rage .